No open-source tool is perfect, and that stands true for Suricata. And while we believe that Suricata’s benefits far outweigh its challenges, you will need to make that decision for yourself. If you are evaluating Suricata vs Zeek or Suricata vs Snort, you should probably have a good understanding of Suricata’s advantages and disadvantages while also being aware of the true price of free software.
What are the disadvantages of Suricata?
Like all open-source intrusion detection tools, Suricata does have some distinct disadvantages:
- Complexity: Suricata offers a high degree of flexibility, but this can also translate to complexity. Setting up, configuring, and maintaining Suricata effectively requires a good understanding of network security concepts, IDS/IPS functionalities, and potentially scripting languages for rule customization. This can be a challenge for organizations with limited security expertise.
- False Positives: Suricata relies on predefined rules and signatures to identify threats. Overly strict or outdated rules can lead to false positives, where legitimate traffic gets flagged as suspicious. This can create unnecessary alerts and waste valuable security personnel time investigating non-existent threats.
- Performance Overhead: While Suricata is known for its speed, it can still consume significant CPU and memory resources, especially when dealing with very high-bandwidth networks. This might necessitate upgrading hardware or implementing distributed deployments to ensure optimal performance.
- Limited Support: Suricata being open-source offers cost advantages, but it also means there's no guaranteed vendor support. While the community is active and helpful, organizations might require additional resources or expertise to troubleshoot complex issues or integrate Suricata with other security tools. A solution to this could be implementing a Suricata-based network detection and response (NDR) system like the Stamus Security Platform.
- Security Expertise Needed: Extracting the most value from Suricata requires skilled security professionals. You'll need personnel who understand threat detection, rule management, and interpreting the vast amount of data Suricata collects. This can be a challenge for organizations with limited security staff.
- Alert Fatigue: Suricata can generate a significant number of alerts, especially in complex network environments. Without proper filtering and prioritization, security personnel can become overwhelmed by alert fatigue, potentially missing critical threats amidst the noise.
Suricata is a powerful and versatile tool, but it's not a one-size-fits-all solution. Consider the complexity, potential for resource consumption, and the need for security expertise when evaluating Suricata for your specific needs. If your organization wants to begin using Suricata, you could also consider deploying a turn-key Suricata-based IDS/NSM and threat-hunting system such as SELKS. This would allow you to use production-grade Suricata without many of the disadvantages caused by configuring your own Suricata solution.
What are the benefits of Suricata?
If you decide that the challenges presented by Suricata are worth finding solutions to (many of which are provided on the Suricata GitHub), then you can enjoy all of the following benefits:
- Speed: Unlike some other IDS tools, Suricata is multi-threaded, meaning it can use multiple CPU cores simultaneously. This allows it to handle complex tasks and analyze vast amounts of traffic in real time, ensuring threats are detected quickly without compromising network performance. Suricata is also designed to manage memory efficiently, minimizing resource consumption and maximizing processing speed.
- Scalability: Suricata can easily adapt to your organization’s needs as it grows. It can be deployed in a distributed fashion, with sensors strategically placed across your network. This allows for wider network coverage and the ability to scale processing power by adding more sensors as your network expands. It can then be configured to prioritize specific network segments or workloads, ensuring optimal performance for critical areas while efficiently handling less sensitive traffic. Because Suricata is so efficient, it can run effectively even on modest hardware. As your organization’s needs grow, you can upgrade hardware or leverage distributed deployments for continued scalability.
- Flexibility: Suricata offers a high degree of customization through extensive rule sets and indicators of compromise (IOCs). Suricata supports various rule sets from multiple sources, including Emerging Threats and Snort rules. You can also create custom rules to address specific vulnerabilities or concerns. Additionally, Suricata can be configured to detect specific indicators associated with known threats, such as malicious IP addresses, URLs, or file hashes. This allows for highly targeted threat detection.
- NSM Functionality: Suricata goes beyond basic IDS/IPS functionalities, tracking network flows to provide valuable insights into network activity patterns and identifying suspicious connections. Suricata can collect various network telemetry data, including packet size, source and destination information, protocol details, and more. This comprehensive data aids in network behavior analysis and threat detection.
- Depth of Data: Suricata provides a wealth of valuable data for various security purposes, including detailed packet inspection, flow data, alert logs, and more. This data is invaluable for forensic analysis after a security breach and can be used for security audits and compliance purposes. Additionally, the detailed data Suricata provides can be fed into your organization’s SIEM, other dedicated security analytics platforms, or a network detection and response (NDR) system to be leveraged by machine learning (ML) and artificial intelligence (AI) engines for advanced threat detection and automated incident response.
Is Suricata a SIEM?
No, Suricata is not a SIEM (Security Information and Event Management) system. They serve different purposes within cybersecurity, though they can work together effectively. Suricata is an IDS/IPS that primarily focuses on analyzing network traffic data packets with predefined Suricata rules and signatures to identify and potentially block malicious activity. A SIEM system is a much broader security tool. It acts as a central hub that collects, aggregates, analyzes, and stores security event data from various sources, which could include Suricata, firewalls, servers, applications, and more. SIEMs offer a wider lens, helping your organization correlate security events across the entire IT environment.
Is Suricata free?
Like most open-source intrusion detection tools, Suricata is free to use. It is important to note that despite being free, other costs could result from a Suricata installation:
- Hardware: Suricata can be resource-intensive, especially when dealing with high volumes of network traffic. You might need to invest in additional hardware with sufficient processing power and memory to run Suricata effectively. This could involve upgrading existing servers or purchasing new ones entirely.
- Setup and Configuration: While Suricata offers a user-friendly interface, proper configuration requires a good understanding of network security concepts and IDS/IPS functionalities. If your IT team lacks this expertise, you might need to hire consultants to help with the initial setup and configuration.
- Maintenance and Updates: Open-source thrives on community contributions, but keeping Suricata up-to-date with the latest rule sets and bug fixes might require some effort from your security team. If you don't have the internal resources, you might consider paid subscription services that offer automated updates and rule management for Suricata.
- Training: Using Suricata effectively often requires training for your IT security personnel. They'll need to understand how to interpret Suricata's alerts, investigate potential threats, and fine-tune the rule sets for optimal performance. Training can be done internally or through external providers.
- Integration with other security tools: Suricata can be a powerful tool, but it might not be the only one in your security arsenal. Integrating Suricata with other security tools like firewalls, SIEM (Security Information and Event Management) systems, and threat intelligence feeds can enhance its effectiveness. Depending on the chosen tools, there might be additional licensing or integration costs involved.
So, while Suricata itself is technically free, there can be some indirect costs associated with its implementation and ongoing use. The extent of these costs will depend on your specific needs, existing infrastructure, and internal IT expertise.
Learn More About Suricata
To begin learning more about Suricata, we recommend downloading the open-source book published by Stamus Networks titled “The Security Analyst’s Guide to Suricata” — the first practical guide to threat detection and hunting using Suricata, the world’s most popular open-source network security engine.
Written for security operations center (SOC) analysts and threat hunters who use Suricata to gain insights into what is taking place on their networks, the book provides vital information on entry points and an in-depth analysis of the most important Suricata features.
To be notified of new blog posts and other news, make sure to subscribe to the Stamus Networks blog, follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn, and Facebook, or join our Discord.
